Life in Kosovo discusses about emergency situations
Tonight, Life in Kosovo will broadcast a debate on the emergency situations in our country.
Read more
Every Thursday starting from 20:30, Radio Television Kosovo, RTK, broadcasts the TV debate show "Life in Kosovo", a joint production of BIRN and RTK.
Read more
Life in Kosovo debates freedom of speech
28 May 2009 This Life in Kosovo show broadcast a debate with representatives from the Kosovo Government and civil society on freedom of speech in Kosovo.
Is there freedom of speech in Kosovo? How much is freedom of speech respected and who are the main violators of it? Who do the Kosovar media serve to: political parties or the people of Kosovo? Are Kosovars free to express their opinions? Who protects this important freedom enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Kosovo?
To discuss these and others related to freedom of speech and free media, Jeta Xharra’s guests for the show were:
Besim Abazi, journalist at Voice of America
Memli Krasniqi, spokesperson of the government of Kosovo
Glauk Konjufca, from Self-Determination movement
Ilir Deda, from KIPRED
The show began with Jeta Xharra’s explaination of the situation. According to Xharra, this topic became an issue of interest when Jakup Krasniqi, the parliament speaker, declared that civil society and the media in Kosovo are orchestrated by the Government.
Speaking about the presence of freedom of speech in Kosovo, Memli Krasniqi, the spokesperson of the government, said that there is a sufficient level of freedom of expression.
“No doubt that there is always more to ask for, more to be ambitious for, and we, as much as we can, without being directly involved, are interested and work to have this horizon as wide as possible and to make it possible for everyone to say what’s on their mind,” added Krasniqi.
However, he believed that Jakup Krasniqi’s statement was taken out of context.
“Jakup Krasniqi’s quote that the media is orchestrated was broadcasted quite often. In fact, he did not say such a thing, it was taken out of context and this caused some confusion to the public.”
Speaking about freedom of speech, Ilir Deda, from KIPRED, said that in Kosovo there is not tradition of freedom of speech.
“Due to the lack of this tradition, if we look thirty years back, the main form of freedom of expression was to say “Kosovo Republic”, “We want a republic”, “Separation from Serbia”,“ added Deda.
Glauk Konjufca, from Self-Determination movement, didn’t believe either Krasniqi or Deda. According to him, the problem comes from the Government and is related to the authority’s strategy in relation to freedom of expression.
“I believe that there is no freedom of speech in Kosovo because there is an entire mechanism of small scale blackmails, threats, phone calls and pressure, different kinds of pressure by which the apparatchiks, or some small bandits, often threaten the freedom of speech in Kosovo either on behalf of the Government or the institutions ,“ noted Konjufca.
Konjufca went on to disclose the cases identified from the Association of Journalists in Kosovo, which, according to him, has counted 18 cases of threats, some of which came from the Government.
“For instance, some days ago, a journalist, Mr Vehbi Kajtazi, was threatened only because he had described in one of his articles in Koha Ditore, how, by some magic, the evidence in the investigation of the burglary in the Prime Minister’s house disappeared,” adding that he even filed criminal charges
Speaking from personal experience, Besim Abazi, from Voice of America, said that there is a struggle for freedom of speech in Kosovo.
“I have had the opportunity to work during different phases of development in this country, where there is a long tradition of struggling for freedom of speech, which means that there’s a tradition of fighting for freedom of speech,” explained Abazi.
Asked whether in the interest of the country, one should hold back the truth, Abazi said that telling the truth is, in fact, an act of great patriotism, so one should do so.
A TV report prepared by Jeta Abazi showed how deputies bowed their heads after the Prime Minister’s call to denounce cases of corruption. The report also featured an in-depth analysis concerning newspapers. The analysis showed that the most-read newspaper, Koha Ditore, did not get the majority of Government advertisements since the LDK-PDK coalition came into existence. An exclusive interview with the authors of the slogan “KPS, how much per kilo?” was also broadcast.
After the reports, Krasniqi expressed his concerns about the way foreign reports on Kosovo are drafted.
“The Freedom House Report for example was absolutely untrue. This was a report, which in 2008 refers to Kosovo as Serbia, a report which used all documents and reports from 2004, 2005, 2006, in reaching its conclusions,” noted Krasniqi.
Moving on to the report of State Department, Deda stressed the threats found by this report.
“There is another part in the State Department report which states explicitly that journalists have received threats from politicians and organised crime. There is another part which says that huge amounts of money were offered to journalists in return for changing their stories. Either to change their story by putting a positive meaning to it or to withdraw the story completely, and this was done by people from the Government.”
As the conversation moved on to discuss individual cases of Government influencing the media, Life in Kosovo broadcast a TV report, prepared by Jeta Abazi, showing how much the municipality has achieved and how many promises made during the electoral campaign where kept for more than a year. The report showed some frank comments from the head of opposition in Skenderaj, who advised the BIRN journalist to be careful. Following this, the journalist and the camerawoman were attacked by a civilian in Skenderaj and were forced to report the case to police.
The discussion in the studio took another dimension after the report was shown.
Speaking about the fact that the mayor of the municipality, Sami Lushtaku, didn’t want to give an interview to Jeta Xharra, and to participate in her municipal debate, Krasniqi said that the experience and the perception of BIRN journalists was not in line with the perception of the citizens of Skenderaj or of the citizens of Kosovo.
While speaking about transparency in this municipality, Krasniqi believed that if Sami Lushtaku refused to give an interview to “Life in Kosovo” it did not mean that he is not transparent; rather, he believed it was a personal choice to decide who he wants to give interviews to.
At the end of the show, Deda concluded that there is one reality in Pristina and a different one in places outside of it.
“Every insecure government wants to control the media. This has constantly happened in Kosovo and will continue so long as we have an insecure government,” noted Deda explaining that the greater freedom of speech there is, the more developed investigative journalism becomes, the bigger the problem this poses to “non-functional governments”.
“For this reason every government in Kosovo, since 2000, 2001, wishes to control the media since this is the only way to communicate with public opinion. If you have critical media, you have a government which should be defended with more than these half arguments,” concluded Deda.
After the show the satirical Kosovo’s-son-in-law sketch was shown.
THE PROCESS OF JUDICIAL APPOINTMENTS AND REAPPOINTMENTS OF JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS
The report on the process of judicial appointments and reappointments analysis the flow of this process, specifically focusing on the bright and dark sides that have marred the process to its final stages.
COURT MONITORING ANNUAL REPORT APRIL 2010 - FEBRUARY 2011
Court monitoring report is published as a result of a continuous monitoring of all municipal and districts courts of Kosovo. The findings of this report are based on the monitoring of 2,147 court hearings, by BIRN monitors.
THE PROCESS OF JUDICIAL APPOINTMENTS
This report presents the results of part of BIRN's court monitoring project, specifically on the process for the appointment and reappointment of judges and prosecutors.
Follow the Paper Trail
\"Follow the Paper Trail\", a guide to document-based journalism in Kosovo, explains relevant laws, access to public documents, how to publish safely, where to find databases on investigative journalism, and how to locate documents online through various search engines.
Courts Monitoring Report 2010
A detailed analytical report about the work and administration of the courts in Prishtina, Peja, Prizren, Gjilan, Mitrovica, Ferizaj, Gjakova, Decan, Vushtrri, Poduleva, Lipjan, Klina and Istog. The report contains important information, collected by the network of monitors, placed in the major municipalities of Kosovo and aims to identify the key problems and issues that the justice system in Kosovo is facing.
REPORT: Monitoring the Courts 2009
Monitoring the work and administration of courts in Prishtina, Peja, Mitrovica, Gjilan, Ferizaj, Vushtrri and Skenderaj.
DIRECTLY ELECTED MAYOR SYSTEM IN LOCAL GOVERNANCE
The report on Directly Elected mayor System in Local Governance aims to provide a critical overview of the rationale and feasibility of the implementation of a municipal governance system that places the mayor as the central executive figure, during the third year of its application. The efficiency of this system was assessed based on the following pillars: the relationship between local government bodies, accountability of the municipal executive, respect for the law, the link between the mayor and the citizens, provision of public services (water supply and waste management, capital investments (in school and road projects)), level of transparency, public consultation and citizen participation in decision-making.
BIRN Report on Monitoring the Education System
Report on monitoring the elementary and high schools in Prishtina: Mitrovica, Ferizaj, Peja and Gjilan
Analytical report of the situation and the problems in the University of Prishtina
Report on Kosovo`s Healthcare System
Monitoring report on all primary, secondary and tertiary (University Clinical Center of Kosovo, UCCK) healthcare institutions in Pristina, Prizren, Peja, Mitrovica, Gjilan, Ferizaj, Gjakova, Klina, Decan, Istog and Vushtrri.
Situation and the Problems at the University of Prishtina
Analytical report of research into the standards and problems at the University of Prishtina. Ten years since the end of the war in Kosovo, the University of Prishtina (UP) continues to suffer from a variety of problems, resulting in persistently low quality courses being offered. For this reason, BIRN conducted research into the problems faced by UP students. The data gathered suggests that, out of the many issues reported, the most significant are: the non-implementation of contemporary teaching and assessment methods, the lack of practical work for students, the lack of appropriate academic literature, arbitrary assessments by
professors and generally poor relationships between students and their professors.
Download Here
Buy DVD
Click here to buy a copy of 'Does Anyone Have a Plan?,' BIRN's feature-length documentary on Kosovo's final status.
"Life in Kosovo" debates also available on DVDs now!
Read more
Post Your Comments
Write your comment on BIRN debates and other activities.With the new web-site BIRN looks forward to receive direct opinions from our readers via comment section.
Read more
Balkan Investigative Reporting Network
The opinions expressed in Balkan Insight are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network.
Comments:
No comments have been posted.